If you’re a lender, servicer, or financial institution, you’re subject to both the Servicemembers Civil Relief Act (SCRA) and the Military Lending Act (MLA). They’re often mentioned together, but they protect different people, cover different products, and impose different requirements.
Confusing the two. or assuming compliance with one means compliance with the other. is how violations happen. For a comprehensive overview of all SCRA requirements, see our SCRA compliance guide. This post focuses specifically on how SCRA and MLA differ.
The Core Difference: When Was the Debt Created?
The single most important distinction:
- SCRA protects debts and obligations that existed before a servicemember enters active duty
- MLA protects credit extended while a servicemember is on active duty
A servicemember signs a car loan in January, then receives orders in March. That loan is covered by the SCRA. pre-service debt with active-duty protections.
The same servicemember, now on active duty, takes out a personal loan in June. That loan is covered by the MLA. credit extended during service.
Both laws can apply to the same person, but to different obligations.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| SCRA (50 U.S.C. Chapter 50) | MLA (10 U.S.C. §987) | |
|---|---|---|
| Enacted | 1940 (updated 2003) | 2006 (expanded 2015) |
| Protects | Active-duty servicemembers (and dependents indirectly) | Active-duty servicemembers, spouses, and covered dependents |
| Applies to | Pre-service debts and obligations | Credit extended during active duty |
| Interest rate cap | 6% (including fees) | 36% MAPR (Military Annual Percentage Rate) |
| What’s included in the cap | Interest, late fees, service charges, renewal charges | Interest, credit insurance premiums, application fees, debt cancellation fees, ancillary product fees |
| Covered products | All financial obligations (mortgages, auto loans, personal loans, credit cards, leases) | Payday loans, vehicle title loans, refund anticipation loans, installment loans, unsecured lines of credit, credit cards |
| Exclusions | None. covers all pre-service obligations | Real estate-secured loans; purchase-money loans (including vehicle purchase loans) |
| Repossession protection | Yes. court order required | No specific repossession provision |
| Foreclosure protection | Yes. court order required, extends 1 year post-service | No specific foreclosure provision |
| Eviction protection | Yes. court order required | Not applicable |
| Lease termination rights | Yes. early termination without penalty (residential + auto) | Not applicable |
| Default judgment protection | Yes. military status affidavit required | Not applicable |
| Disclosure requirements | Limited (HUD mortgage delinquency disclosures) | Extensive. MAPR statement, payment descriptions, Reg Z disclosures (oral and written) |
| Mandatory arbitration | Not addressed | Prohibited. no mandatory arbitration clauses |
| Waiver of rights | Allowed only with strict requirements (separate document, 12pt type, signed during/after service) | No waiver permitted. any waiver is void |
| Verification method | DMDC database | DMDC or MLA-specific database; “safe harbor” available |
| Enforced by | DOJ, CFPB | CFPB, federal banking regulators, DOD |
| Criminal penalties | Yes. false affidavits, knowing violations | Yes. knowing violations |
| Civil penalties | $79,380 first offense, $158,761 subsequent (July 2025 inflation-adjusted) | Varies; CFPB enforcement actions can be substantial |
Key Differences That Trip Up Lenders
1. The Interest Rate Caps Are Very Different
SCRA caps interest at 6% on pre-service obligations. MLA caps at 36% MAPR on during-service credit.
But the 36% MLA cap is calculated differently than a standard APR. The MAPR includes credit insurance premiums, application fees, participation fees, debt cancellation fees, and other charges that aren’t part of a standard APR disclosure. A loan that appears to be 29% APR may actually be 42% MAPR once all fees are included. making it an MLA violation.
Common mistake: Assuming your standard APR calculation satisfies MLA requirements. It doesn’t. You need a separate MAPR calculation that captures all the components the MLA specifies.
2. The MLA Excludes Real Estate and Vehicle Purchase Loans
The MLA does not cover mortgages, home equity loans, or loans to finance vehicle purchases. The SCRA covers all of these.
This means a vehicle purchase loan is SCRA-protected (if pre-service) but not MLA-protected (even if originated during service). However, a vehicle title loan. using the vehicle as collateral rather than financing its purchase. is covered by the MLA.
Common mistake: Assuming “auto lending” is either fully covered or fully excluded. The distinction between purchase-money loans and title loans matters.
3. MLA Prohibits Mandatory Arbitration; SCRA Doesn’t
The MLA voids any mandatory arbitration clause in covered credit agreements. Servicemembers can always take MLA disputes to court.
The SCRA doesn’t address arbitration. though Santander Consumer USA’s attempt to use an arbitration clause to block an SCRA class action is what triggered the DOJ investigation that led to their $9.35 million settlement. Using arbitration to suppress SCRA claims draws regulatory attention, and the resulting consent decree imposes far greater costs than the original dispute.
4. SCRA Rights Can Be Waived (With Conditions); MLA Rights Cannot
SCRA protections can be waived, but only under strict conditions: a separate written document, signed during or after military service, in 12-point type or larger, specifically identifying the rights being waived. Several states (North Carolina, Florida) make SCRA rights non-waivable regardless.
MLA rights cannot be waived at all. Any waiver provision in a covered credit agreement is void.
5. Covered Persons Are Defined Differently
SCRA protects the servicemember directly. Dependents receive indirect protection (e.g., eviction protection extends to dependents).
MLA protects servicemembers, their spouses, and covered dependents at the time of origination. This means a spouse applying for credit independently can be MLA-protected, requiring the lender to check not just the applicant’s status but whether they’re a military dependent.
What Both Laws Require You to Do
Despite their differences, both laws demand the same foundational capability: you must be able to identify who is a servicemember in your portfolio.
Whether the obligation is pre-service (SCRA) or during-service (MLA), compliance starts with knowing who you’re dealing with. That means:
- Verify military status at origination (for MLA) and on an ongoing basis (for SCRA)
- Apply the correct protections based on when the obligation was created
- Document everything. regulators enforce both laws and expect audit-ready records
- Monitor continuously. military status changes as Reservists and Guard members cycle in and out
The Compliance Overlap
Most servicemembers will have both SCRA-protected and MLA-protected obligations simultaneously. A single customer might have:
- A mortgage (SCRA only. MLA excludes real estate)
- A credit card opened before service (SCRA)
- A credit card opened during service (MLA)
- A personal loan opened during service (MLA)
- An auto purchase loan from before service (SCRA only. MLA excludes purchase-money loans)
Managing this requires knowing not just who is a servicemember, but when each obligation was created relative to their service dates. Manual tracking across a portfolio of thousands is where compliance breaks down.
Sources: Experian: MLA and SCRA Differences; CFPB: SCRA and MLA Protections; OCC Comptroller’s Handbook: SCRA
$400 million+ in SCRA settlements and penalties. Every one started with a process gap that could have been caught. How confident are you in yours?
Check Your Exposure → · See Pricing →
Related training
See these topics covered in depth in our free SCRA training videos. Watch now →
Ready to automate your SCRA compliance?
See how civrel.io replaces manual processes with continuous, automated monitoring.