← Blog | Enforcement & Compliance

SCRA Penalties in 2026: Civil, Criminal, and Private Action Consequences

March 12, 2026 · Updated November 14, 2026 · Mario Bailey
Share

Many resources still list the SCRA civil penalty as $55,000 for a first violation and $110,000 for a subsequent one. Those are the base amounts written into 50 U.S.C. § 4041(b)(3). The Justice Department adjusts them for inflation every year in 28 CFR § 85.5, and the adjustment in force since July 3, 2025 sets the maximums at $79,380 and $158,761.

If your compliance team is still using the base numbers in risk assessments, the per-violation ceiling in those calculations is understated by about 44%.

A correction, November 14, 2026: an earlier version of this guide said the $55,000 and $110,000 figures were in force until 2024 and were “superseded on July 3, 2025” (they are the statutory base, and the amounts in force before February 12, 2024 were $74,941 and $149,883); said Santander paid $9.35 million for 760 repossessions (the settlement covered 1,112 servicemembers, and its civil penalty was $55,000); cited a $56 million JPMorgan Chase class action we could not confirm from a primary record; listed consent decree terms, such as an independent monitor and quarterly reporting in every case, that named settlements do not all contain; cited § 4042(b) for the right to sue (it is § 4042(a)); and gave enforcement counts by administration without a primary source. Those statements have been corrected or removed.

This guide covers every penalty mechanism the federal government and private plaintiffs can use against organizations that violate the Servicemembers Civil Relief Act.

Civil Penalties Under the SCRA

The DOJ enforces the SCRA under 50 U.S.C. §4041 (formerly §597). Civil penalties are assessed per violation:

First OffenseSubsequent Offense
Current (July 3, 2025)$79,380$158,761
Previous (Feb 2024)$77,370$154,741
Before Feb 12, 2024$74,941$149,883
Statutory base, § 4041(b)(3)$55,000$110,000

These figures adjust annually under the Federal Civil Penalties Inflation Adjustment Act Improvements Act of 2015. They are maximums: a court sets the actual penalty, and in a settlement it is negotiated.

How Penalties Multiply

A single compliance gap can produce dozens or hundreds of violations. Each affected servicemember typically constitutes a separate violation.

Recent examples:

  • Santander Consumer USA (2015): at least $9.35 million covering 1,112 servicemembers: $10,000 plus lost equity for each of 760 repossessions without court orders, $5,000 for each of 352 servicemembers from whom it sought fees on unlawful repossessions by earlier lenders, and a $55,000 civil penalty, the maximum for a first violation at the time.
  • Hyundai Capital America: $333,941 for 26 servicemembers ($74,941 civil penalty + $259,000 compensation). The civil penalty alone was roughly $2,882 per violation.
  • CarMax: at least $420,000 to servicemembers for 28 repossessed vehicles, plus a $79,380 civil penalty.
  • Greystar Real Estate Partners: $1,427,370 in all: $1.35 million set aside for servicemembers and co-tenants charged improper lease termination fees (triple the charges for those who paid), plus a $77,370 civil penalty.

In each case most of the money went to servicemembers; the civil penalty was a small share of the total. The DOJ’s stated total across all SCRA enforcement actions since 2011 is over $490 million in monetary relief for over 153,000 servicemembers (October 2026).

Beyond Civil Penalties: The Full Penalty Stack

Civil penalties under §4041 are only one enforcement mechanism. Organizations that violate the SCRA face exposure on multiple fronts simultaneously.

The civil penalty is the headline number. The consent decree or settlement agreement carries the rest of the cost. Terms vary by case. Examples from the settlements themselves:

  • Compensation, sometimes above the amount charged: Greystar’s agreement pays triple the improper charges to those who paid them
  • A review of past accounts: Santander’s settlement required it to review its other repossessions for further SCRA violations, and Greystar’s requires an independent consultant to review its military lease terminations back to July 1, 2018
  • New SCRA policies and procedures, and employee training: required in Lincoln Military Housing’s, Hyundai’s and Westlake’s settlements, among others
  • Credit repair for each affected servicemember: required in the Santander, Hyundai and Westlake settlements
  • Reporting to the DOJ for a fixed term: Greystar’s agreement runs five years with accountings every six months; Santander’s consent order also runs five years

Each of those terms costs money and staff time for years after the penalty is paid.

Criminal Penalties

The SCRA includes criminal penalties in several substantive sections. Under §3953(d), anyone who knowingly makes or causes to be made a sale, foreclosure, or seizure of property prohibited by the SCRA may be fined, imprisoned for up to one year, or both. Similar criminal provisions apply to illegal evictions (§3951), repossessions (§3952), and false affidavits of non-military-service (§3931(c)).

Each of these provisions requires that the person acted knowingly (§ 3931(c) requires that the person knew the affidavit was false).

Private Right of Action

Servicemembers can sue directly under 50 U.S.C. § 4042(a), which lets a person aggrieved by a violation:

  • Obtain equitable or declaratory relief (for example, a court order to stop the violating conduct)
  • Recover “all other appropriate relief, including monetary damages”
  • Recover costs and a reasonable attorney fee if they prevail (§ 4042(b))

The statute does not cap or itemize those damages, so a private case’s cost depends on the court and the facts. Section 4042(c) adds that this right is in addition to, not in place of, any other remedy.

State-Level Penalties

Many states have enacted their own military protection statutes that supplement the federal SCRA. Some impose additional penalties:

  • States with enhanced eviction protections may impose separate fines for violations
  • Some states allow treble damages in private actions involving servicemember protections
  • State attorneys general may enforce their own state’s military protection laws

For a detailed overview of state-level protections, see our state military protections guide.

How Penalties Are Calculated in Practice

The DOJ does not publish a formula for SCRA settlements, but the settlements show what drives the total: how many servicemembers were affected and what happened to them. A repossession or foreclosure is compensated per person (Santander paid $10,000 plus lost equity for each repossession), while an interest overcharge is usually refunded with a multiple (Westlake’s 2022 amendment paid the excess interest plus three times the overpayment or $100, whichever was higher).

That is why totals vary so widely. Santander paid at least $9.35 million for 1,112 servicemembers, while BayPort Credit Union paid $109,443 for 21 interest rate cap cases and three repossessions.

The Enforcement Trend

By its own count, the DOJ has obtained over $490 million in monetary relief for over 153,000 servicemembers since 2011 (October 2026), and its case list shows new settlements as recently as 2026.

For a detailed analysis of recent enforcement trends, see our SCRA enforcement update.

Calculating Your Exposure

The formula for estimating SCRA penalty exposure is straightforward:

Estimated SCRA-protected accounts × per-violation penalty = maximum exposure

If your portfolio has 50,000 accounts and roughly 0.5% of U.S. adults are active-duty military (approximately 1% including Selected Reserve and National Guard), you have an estimated 250-500 SCRA-protected accounts at any given time.

If even 10% of those accounts have an undetected compliance gap (a missed rate cap, an adverse action without military status verification), the civil penalty ceiling alone is:

50 accounts × $79,380 = $3.97 million (first violation maximum)

That does not include victim compensation, consent decree costs, or private litigation.


What’s your actual exposure? Most organizations don’t know how many servicemembers are in their portfolio. Find out in 30 seconds.

Check Your Exposure →

Sources: 50 U.S.C. § 4041, § 4042, § 3931, § 3951, § 3952, § 3953; 28 CFR § 85.5 (current and prior versions); DOJ press releases on Santander (2015), Hyundai Capital America (2024), CarMax, Greystar, Westlake (2022), BayPort Credit Union and Village Capital (2026). All checked November 14, 2026. Claims in DOJ complaints are allegations, resolved by settlement.

Related training

See these topics covered in depth in our free SCRA training videos. Watch now →

Mario Bailey, Founder & CEO of Civrel

Mario Bailey · Founder & CEO, Civrel

Mario serves in the Air National Guard (Cyber Systems Operations) and spent ten years as a software engineer before founding Civrel. He has been on the receiving end of SCRA compliance: getting his own protections applied took longer than it should have, and he built Civrel so institutions can get it right.

LinkedIn | About Civrel →

Disclaimer: This content is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. SCRA obligations depend on your institution's specific facts and on applicable federal and state law. Consult qualified counsel before acting on anything you read here.

Ready to automate your SCRA compliance?

See how civrel.io replaces manual processes with continuous, automated monitoring.