Santander's $9.35 Million SCRA Settlement: 1,112 Repossessed Vehicles
Published · Updated
This violation could have been prevented with automated SCRA compliance. Watch free training or see how Civrel works.
On February 25, 2015, the Department of Justice announced that Santander Consumer USA Inc. had agreed to pay at least $9.35 million to resolve a lawsuit alleging that it violated the Servicemembers Civil Relief Act. The complaint and the proposed consent order were filed the same day in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas, where Santander is headquartered. The DOJ called it the largest settlement for illegal automobile repossessions the United States had ever obtained under the SCRA.
The settlement covers 1,112 vehicles, in two groups. The DOJ alleged that Santander itself repossessed 760 vehicles owned by SCRA-protected servicemembers without court orders between January 1, 2008 and February 28, 2013, and that it tried to collect fees arising from another 352 repossessions that other lenders had carried out in violation of the SCRA before Santander acquired the loans.
A correction, November 14, 2026: an earlier version of this page dated the announcement March 5, 2015, said all 1,112 vehicles were seized by Santander, said Santander had SCRA verification policies on paper that it applied inconsistently, and said Section 3952 requires the court to find that military service does not affect the borrower’s ability to pay before it allows a repossession. The DOJ alleged that Santander had no policy to check the Defense Department’s database before repossessing until about September 2012, and the statute requires a court order without setting that finding as a condition. The page also listed settlement terms the consent order does not contain. The page now follows the DOJ announcement, the complaint and the consent order.
What the DOJ alleged
The case rests on 50 U.S.C. § 3952(a). After a servicemember enters military service, a contract to buy or lease property, including a motor vehicle, “may not be rescinded or terminated for a breach of terms of the contract occurring before or during that person’s military service, nor may the property be repossessed for such breach without a court order.” The protection applies when the servicemember paid a deposit or installment before entering service. In a hearing, the court may order repayment of prior installments as a condition of repossession, must stay the proceedings on the servicemember’s application when military service materially affects the ability to comply, or may make another equitable disposition.
According to the complaint:
- The DOJ first heard of the practice through a referral from the U.S. Army’s Legal Assistance Program about 19-year-old Army Specialist Joshua Davis. Santander’s agent recorded that he said he was leaving for boot camp the next day. Santander ordered the repossession while he was at basic training, seized the car from outside his home in the middle of the night, sold it at auction, and billed him a deficiency of over $9,000.
- In May 2012, Santander used the arbitration clause in its loan documents to stop an Army National Guard sergeant from pursuing a class action alleging the same kind of repossessions.
- Santander conducted repossessions even when its own records showed the borrower was SCRA-protected.
- Until approximately September 2012, Santander had no policy to check the Defense Department’s automated system before conducting repossessions.
The DOJ opened its investigation on January 31, 2013 and reviewed data on every Santander repossession from January 1, 2008 through February 28, 2013.
What the consent order required
From the DOJ’s announcement and the consent order:
- $10,000 plus any lost equity, with interest, to each servicemember whose vehicle Santander repossessed without a court order (760 identified)
- $5,000 to each servicemember from whom Santander sought to collect fees on another lender’s unlawful repossession (352 identified)
- Repair of the credit of every affected servicemember
- A review, with compensation, of any further unlawful repossessions after February 2013
- A $55,000 civil penalty to the United States
- SCRA policies and procedures under which every borrower on a motor vehicle loan is checked against the Defense Manpower Data Center (DMDC) database and Santander’s own records at least every seven days for the life of the loan, until at least two business days after the vehicle is disposed of
- No referral for repossession, and no repossession, of a protected servicemember’s vehicle without a court order; and if Santander learns after taking a vehicle that the borrower is protected, an offer to return it within 24 hours and reversal of the repossession charges
- SCRA training for covered employees, repeated annually during the order
- A five-year term
The settlement was subject to court approval when it was announced. The DOJ said an independent settlement administrator would contact the servicemembers identified in its investigation.
Santander came back in 2021
On September 30, 2021, the DOJ filed and settled a second SCRA lawsuit against Santander, doing business as Chrysler Capital, in the same court. This time the allegation was that it denied early motor vehicle lease terminations to ten servicemembers who qualified for them. One was an Army captain who learned he was deploying to Afghanistan, returned his leased Jeep in August 2019, and was refused until February 2020, after the DOJ had opened its investigation. Santander agreed to pay $94,282.62 to the ten servicemembers and a $40,000 civil penalty.
What went wrong
No database check before repossession. By the DOJ’s account, for most of the period under review Santander had no policy of checking the Defense Department’s system before it repossessed a car. A free check that is never run cannot catch anything.
Information the company already had was ignored. The Davis repossession went ahead after a Santander agent wrote down that the borrower was leaving for boot camp. A control that does not reach the repossession decision is not a control.
Acquired loans carried someone else’s violations. Santander bought loans from other lenders and then tried to collect fees from 352 repossessions those lenders had conducted unlawfully. Buying a portfolio does not clean its history: collecting on an unlawful repossession was itself part of the case.
Lessons for the industry
Check every loan, on a schedule, not only at referral. The consent order did not settle for a one-time check before repossession. It required a check of every motor vehicle borrower at least weekly for the life of the loan. Military status changes, and the check has to keep up with it.
Wire customer notices into collections. A borrower who tells customer service about orders has given the company notice. That information has to stop the repossession, not sit in a call note.
Price the exposure per vehicle. The order set $10,000 plus lost equity for each unlawful repossession and $5,000 for each unlawful fee collection, and later DOJ auto cases have used the same $10,000 starting point. Multiply by the number of repossessions run without a status check.
Leases are covered too. The 2021 case shows the DOJ looks at the whole auto relationship, including lease terminations under 50 U.S.C. § 3955, not only repossessions.
How Civrel Prevents This
The DOJ described two gaps at Santander: no military status check before repossession, and borrower information that never reached the repossession decision. Civrel is built around both.
Mandatory DMDC verification before every adverse action. Civrel integrates military status verification directly into the repossession workflow. Every account is checked against DMDC before any adverse action proceeds. There is no option to skip, override, or defer the check. The verification is a hard gate, not a suggestion.
Automated hold on protected accounts. When a DMDC check identifies a servicemember as active-duty with a pre-service contract, Civrel automatically flags the account and blocks the repossession. The account is routed for legal review under Section 3952. No manual intervention is required to apply the hold, and no manual override can remove it without documented legal authorization.
Audit trail for every decision. Every DMDC check, every hold, every routing decision is logged with timestamps and user attribution. If the DOJ asks whether you verified military status before a specific repossession, you have the answer immediately, not in a spreadsheet search, but in an auditable compliance record.
Enterprise-wide consistency. Civrel applies the same verification and hold process to every account in the system, regardless of volume. Whether a lender services ten thousand accounts or ten million, the SCRA compliance process is identical for each one. Scale does not create compliance gaps because the process is automated, not manual.
Sources: DOJ press release, February 25, 2015; complaint, United States v. Santander Consumer USA Inc., No. 3:15-cv-633 (N.D. Tex.) (DOJ, PDF); consent order (DOJ, PDF); DOJ press release, September 30, 2021; 50 U.S.C. § 3952. All checked November 14, 2026. The claims in the complaints were allegations, resolved by consent order.
Disclaimer: This content is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. SCRA obligations depend on your institution's specific facts and on applicable federal and state law. Consult qualified counsel before acting on anything you read here.
See how civrel.io prevents these violations
Automated DMDC verification before every adverse action, consent-decree-grade documentation, and continuous monitoring.