PRG Real Estate's $1.59 Million Settlement: The Largest SCRA Case Against a Property Manager
Published · Updated
This violation could have been prevented with automated SCRA compliance. Watch free training or see how Civrel works.
On March 15, 2019, the Department of Justice announced that PRG Real Estate Management and several related entities had agreed to pay up to $1,590,000 to resolve allegations that they violated the Servicemembers Civil Relief Act. The DOJ said it was the largest settlement it had ever obtained against a landlord or property management company for SCRA violations.
The case had two parts. Most of the money was for default judgments PRG obtained against servicemember-tenants in Virginia courts without telling the court they were in the military. A smaller part was for fees PRG charged servicemembers who ended their leases early under military orders.
What the DOJ alleged
The DOJ’s complaint, filed March 14, 2019 in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia, alleged that from 2006 to 2017 PRG obtained at least 152 default judgments against 127 SCRA-protected servicemembers, either by failing to disclose their military service to the court or by falsely stating that they were not in the military. The judgments were eviction and money judgments in Virginia state courts.
The rule PRG was accused of breaking sits in 50 U.S.C. § 3931. When a defendant does not appear, the court cannot enter a judgment for the plaintiff until the plaintiff files an affidavit stating whether the defendant is in military service, with facts to support it, or stating that it could not determine the answer. If the defendant is in military service, the court must appoint an attorney before entering judgment, and the court must stay the case for at least 90 days if that attorney cannot reach the servicemember or the servicemember may have a defense.
The complaint also alleged that PRG imposed early termination charges on servicemember-tenants who ended their leases under military orders. Under 50 U.S.C. § 3955, a servicemember who enters military service after signing a residential lease, or who signs one while serving and then receives permanent change of station orders or orders to deploy for at least 90 days, may terminate it, and the landlord may not impose an early termination charge.
The investigation began after Navy legal assistance attorneys in Norfolk, Virginia reported the judgments to the Department.
The settlement
From the DOJ announcement and the case page, PRG agreed to:
- Pay up to $1,490,000 to compensate 127 servicemembers who had 152 unlawful default judgments entered against them
- Pay $34,920.39 to compensate 10 servicemembers who were charged early lease termination fees
- Pay a civil penalty of $62,029 to the United States
- Repair the credit of affected servicemembers
- Train its employees on the SCRA and adopt new policies and procedures consistent with it
- Accept monitoring for SCRA compliance
Under the settlement, an independent administrator was to locate the servicemembers and pay them at no cost to them. The compensated tenants lived at six properties: Linkhorn Bay Apartments and The Courtyards of Chanticleer in Virginia Beach, Hilton Village Townhomes and Heritage Trace Apartments in Newport News, and Hyde Park Apartments and Ashton Creek in Chester.
A correction, November 14, 2026: an earlier version of this page said PRG “filed 152 false affidavits”, listed DMDC verification before every court filing as a settlement term, and said a military status affidavit is required for every eviction, repossession, and court action. The DOJ alleged 152 default judgments obtained by failing to disclose military service or by stating it falsely; the announcement lists training, policies, credit repair, and monitoring, not a specific DMDC term; and § 3931 requires the affidavit before a default judgment, when the defendant has not appeared.
What went wrong
Status was never checked before the filing. The DOJ pointed out that landlords can verify military status through the Defense Manpower Data Center’s free public website, or by looking in their own files for applications, leave and earnings statements, or military orders. A tenant’s own rental file often carries exactly the information needed.
The affidavit was treated as paperwork. The affidavit is the court’s only way to know that the absent tenant may be serving. When it is left out or filled in without checking, the court enters a judgment the SCRA says it should not enter without first appointing an attorney.
It ran for eleven years. The judgments the DOJ cited span 2006 to 2017. A process gap repeated across every delinquent account becomes a list of 152 judgments.
The false affidavit risk
Under 50 U.S.C. § 3931(c), a person who makes or uses a military status affidavit knowing it to be false can be fined under title 18, imprisoned for up to one year, or both. The PRG case was civil and alleged a pattern of inaccurate or missing affidavits; it did not charge anyone criminally. But the criminal penalty is the reason the affidavit deserves a real check behind it, not a default answer.
What would have prevented it
One step at the right moment: verify military status before asking any court for a default judgment, and keep the result with the affidavit. If the check shows the tenant is serving, the filing needs to say so, and the case moves to the SCRA’s appointed-counsel and stay procedures rather than to judgment.
A second step for the fee claims: when a tenant hands over permanent change of station or deployment orders with a termination notice, the lease ends on the date § 3955 sets, with no termination charge.
Sources: DOJ press release, March 15, 2019; DOJ case page, United States v. PRG Real Estate Management (E.D. Va.), with the complaint and settlement agreement; 50 U.S.C. § 3931 and § 3955. All checked November 14, 2026. The civil claims settled are allegations only; there has been no determination of civil liability.
Disclaimer: This content is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. SCRA obligations depend on your institution's specific facts and on applicable federal and state law. Consult qualified counsel before acting on anything you read here.
See how civrel.io prevents these violations
Automated DMDC verification before every adverse action, consent-decree-grade documentation, and continuous monitoring.