← Enforcement Tracker | Banking & Mortgage

JPMorgan Chase's SCRA Foreclosure Settlement: $59.9 Million to 392 Servicemembers

Published · Updated

Settlement
$59,912,851
Year
2012
Servicemembers
392
Jurisdiction
D.D.C.

This violation could have been prevented with automated SCRA compliance. Watch free training or see how Civrel works.

On February 9, 2012, alongside the $25 billion federal-state National Mortgage Settlement, the Department of Justice announced a separate agreement to compensate servicemembers who were wrongfully foreclosed on by four of the five largest mortgage servicers: JPMorgan Chase, Wells Fargo, Citigroup, and Ally (formerly GMAC). The servicemember compensation was in addition to the $25 billion. The JPMorgan Chase investigation was handled by the Justice Department’s Civil Rights Division and the U.S. Attorney’s Office in South Carolina.

Under the agreement, J.P. Morgan Chase Bank, N.A. had an independent consultant review every completed foreclosure from January 1, 2006 forward for compliance with the SCRA’s foreclosure and default judgment provisions. By September 2015 the DOJ reported that JPMorgan Chase owed $32,488,293 to 188 servicemembers and co-borrowers for non-judicial foreclosures and $27,424,558 to 204 for judicial foreclosures: $59,912,851 for 392 in all.

A correction, November 14, 2026: an earlier version of this page gave the settlement as about $31 million for 188 servicemembers, which was the DOJ’s February 2015 figure for non-judicial foreclosures alone, and left out the judicial foreclosures. It also said the case turned on accounts inherited from Washington Mutual, when the DOJ agreement expressly does not cover Washington Mutual’s servicing before September 25, 2008; said “thousands” of servicemembers were overcharged interest and compensated under this agreement, when the DOJ said Chase had already compensated rate cap overcharges through an earlier private settlement; gave a $56 million figure for the Rowles v. Chase class action and an $87 million combined total, which we could not confirm in a primary source; and listed settlement terms (a dedicated compliance officer, a 30-day rate cap deadline) that the agreement does not contain. The page now follows the DOJ announcements and the agreement itself.

What the agreement covered

The DOJ released its potential SCRA claims against the bank in two areas: mortgage foreclosure, and charging more than 6 percent interest on a covered mortgage after a valid request. The agreement, filed as an exhibit to the National Mortgage Settlement in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, turns on two sections of the SCRA, cited in the agreement by their original numbers:

Foreclosure without a court order (Section 533, now 50 U.S.C. § 3953). A sale, foreclosure, or seizure on a mortgage the servicemember took out before entering military service is not valid if it happens during military service or within one year after it ends, unless a court orders it first or it is made under a valid written agreement. In a non-judicial foreclosure state, no court is involved unless the servicer brings one in.

Default judgment without a proper affidavit (Section 521, now 50 U.S.C. § 3931). In a court foreclosure where the borrower does not appear, the plaintiff must file an affidavit stating whether the borrower is in military service before the court enters a default judgment. If the borrower is serving, the court must appoint an attorney, and the DOJ noted that it may stay the case for at least 90 days.

The agreement does not apply to servicing by Washington Mutual Bank before JPMorgan Chase acquired certain of its assets on September 25, 2008. The United States reserved any SCRA claims it might have over Washington Mutual’s conduct.

What the agreement required

Compensation. For any newly identified servicemember or co-borrower whose foreclosure the DOJ found did not comply with the SCRA, and who had not already been compensated in the Rowles v. Chase class action settlement, Chase had to rescind the sale where possible and forgive the remaining mortgage debt; or, if the sale could not be rescinded, pay the full value of the home at the time of sale (the higher of the sale price or the appraised value), waive any deficiency, and forgive the remaining debt. A special consultant, retired U.S. District Judge Edward N. Cahn, would recommend additional damages consistent with awards from the Rowles settlement. Chase also had to ask all three credit bureaus to remove the related negative entries.

Interest rate cap. The DOJ’s 2012 announcement said JPMorgan Chase had already compensated servicemembers charged more than 6 percent on their mortgages through the earlier private settlement. The agreement set policies going forward: accept rate reduction requests by email, fax, mail, and overnight delivery (and in person at branches within six months); accept orders without requiring an end date; check the Defense Manpower Data Center (DMDC) website before concluding that the rate may rise above 6 percent, and keep it capped while DMDC shows active duty; and explain any denial in writing.

Foreclosure policies. Before referring a loan to foreclosure, Chase had to review any orders it had received and check the borrower against the DMDC website. In a court foreclosure where the borrower did not answer, Chase or its agent had to query DMDC before seeking a default and, if the borrower was in military service, file an affidavit saying so with the DMDC certificate or orders attached. A waiver had to be offered at least 30 days before a scheduled sale, using a prescribed notice.

Training and monitoring. SCRA training, approved by the DOJ, for employees who serve servicemembers, adjust mortgage interest rates, or handle foreclosures, and confirmation that outside vendors, law firms, and trustees had trained theirs. A DOJ-approved monitoring program with a quarterly report analyzing samples of foreclosures and rate cap requests.

Term. Three and a half years from entry, with quarterly reporting continuing six months beyond.

What went wrong

The foreclosure checkpoint was missing in both kinds of states. The compensation divides almost evenly between non-judicial foreclosures (188 servicemembers and co-borrowers) and judicial ones (204). In non-judicial states, the failure was selling without a court order. In judicial states, it was obtaining a default without a proper military affidavit. Both trace back to one question not being asked before the foreclosure moved: is this borrower in military service?

Private litigation came first. The DOJ agreement was written around an existing class action settlement, Rowles v. Chase. Servicemembers already compensated there were excluded from new compensation, and damages awards were tied to that settlement’s fund. Private SCRA litigation can be a leading indicator of federal enforcement.

Lessons for the industry

Acquisitions carry SCRA history. The DOJ carved Washington Mutual’s pre-acquisition servicing out of this agreement and reserved its claims over it. A buyer of a servicing portfolio should assume SCRA questions about the seller’s conduct are not settled by its own agreements.

The affidavit is a control, not a form. About half of Chase’s compensated borrowers were in judicial foreclosures, where a court was involved and a default was entered anyway. The affidavit has to reflect an actual check of status before the default is requested.

Price the exposure per file. For newly identified borrowers, the remedy was the home back or its full value, plus additional damages. Across the five servicers the DOJ reported more than $311 million for 2,413 servicemembers and co-borrowers.

How Civrel Prevents This

JPMorgan’s case shows two failure points the agreement was written to close: no status check before foreclosure referral, and default judgments sought without a status check behind the affidavit. It also shows the separate risk of a portfolio acquired from another servicer.

Portfolio onboarding with SCRA screening. When a financial institution acquires or onboards a new portfolio, Civrel can screen the entire portfolio against DMDC to identify servicemembers and apply protections before any adverse action occurs. There is no gap period where acquired accounts are serviced without SCRA controls. Protection begins at onboarding.

Mandatory verification before foreclosure. Civrel integrates DMDC verification as a mandatory, non-bypassable step in the foreclosure workflow. If a borrower is on active duty or within the post-service protection period under Section 3953, the foreclosure is automatically blocked. The account is flagged, held, and routed for legal review. No foreclosure proceeds without a verified military status check.

Automated interest rate cap compliance. Civrel processes 6% interest rate cap requests under Section 3937 automatically. The system identifies the pre-service obligation, calculates the rate reduction retroactive to the date the servicemember was called to military service, forgives the excess interest, and adjusts the account. The calculation is consistent across every account because it is performed by the system, not by a servicing representative working through a manual process.

Continuous monitoring and audit trail. Civrel maintains a complete audit trail of every DMDC check, every hold decision, every interest rate adjustment, and every compliance action. Quarterly DOJ reporting requirements under a consent decree can be generated directly from the system. When regulators ask for proof of compliance, the documentation is immediate, complete, and verifiable.


Sources: DOJ press release, February 9, 2012 (servicemember agreement); USDOJ SCRA settlement provisions: J.P. Morgan Chase Bank, N.A., filed in No. 1:12-cv-00361 (D.D.C.) (DOJ, PDF); DOJ press release, February 9, 2015 (non-judicial payments by servicer); DOJ press release, September 30, 2015 (judicial and non-judicial payments by servicer); 50 U.S.C. § 3931; 50 U.S.C. § 3953. All checked November 14, 2026. The claims were allegations, resolved by settlement.

Disclaimer: This content is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. SCRA obligations depend on your institution's specific facts and on applicable federal and state law. Consult qualified counsel before acting on anything you read here.

See how civrel.io prevents these violations

Automated DMDC verification before every adverse action, consent-decree-grade documentation, and continuous monitoring.