Capital One's $12 Million SCRA Settlement: One of the Most Comprehensive Enforcement Actions
Published · Updated
This violation could have been prevented with automated SCRA compliance. Watch free training or see how Civrel works.
On July 26, 2012, the Department of Justice announced that Capital One N.A. and Capital One Bank (USA) N.A. would pay approximately $12 million to resolve a lawsuit alleging violations of the Servicemembers Civil Relief Act. The DOJ described the proposed consent order, filed in federal court in Alexandria, Virginia at the same time as the complaint, as “one of the most comprehensive SCRA settlements ever obtained by a government agency or any private party under the SCRA.”
It was comprehensive because the alleged violations ran across the bank: mortgages, auto loans, credit cards, and the collection lawsuits behind them. The whole case started with one servicemember’s credit card.
What the DOJ alleged
The complaint alleged that from at least July 15, 2006 to November 21, 2011, Capital One:
- Wrongly denied written requests from SCRA-protected servicemembers to lower the interest rate on credit cards and motor vehicle loans to 6% a year
- Gave insufficient interest rate benefits on accounts it did enroll after receiving those requests
- Foreclosed on the mortgages of SCRA-protected servicemembers without court orders
- Repossessed SCRA-protected servicemembers’ vehicles without court orders
- Obtained default judgments on credit card, mortgage, and vehicle debts without filing accurate affidavits of military service
Each maps to a separate section of the statute: the rate cap in 50 U.S.C. § 3937, foreclosure in § 3953, repossession in § 3952, and default judgments in § 3931. Under § 3952, a vehicle bought on an installment contract cannot be repossessed during military service without a court order if the servicemember paid a deposit or installment before entering service.
The lawsuit began with a referral from the Office of the Staff Judge Advocate at Davis-Monthan Air Force Base in Arizona, about a single servicemember who had not received an interest rate reduction on his Capital One credit card. The settlement followed a two-year investigation.
The settlement
According to the DOJ announcement and the consent order, Capital One agreed to:
- Pay approximately $7 million in damages to servicemembers for SCRA violations
- Pay at least $125,000, plus any lost equity with interest, to each servicemember whose home was unlawfully foreclosed on
- Pay at least $10,000, plus any lost equity with interest, to each servicemember whose vehicle was unlawfully repossessed
- Fund $5 million to compensate servicemembers who did not receive the right SCRA benefits on credit card accounts, motor vehicle loans, and consumer loans, with any remainder donated to charities that assist servicemembers
- Identify and compensate servicemembers on accounts dating back to July 15, 2006, with no action required on their part
- Treat a request for 6% rate relief on one account, such as a credit card, as a request for every loan the servicemember holds with Capital One or its affiliates
- Pay beyond the $12 million if required independent audits found violations in the accounts it had recently acquired from HSBC and ING Direct USA
- Adopt policies and practices to prevent future SCRA violations
The DOJ said this was the first time it had obtained enterprise-wide rate reduction relief from a lender under the SCRA. It also noted that Capital One had cooperated fully and had, on its own initiative, extended a 4% rate to qualifying servicemembers and added a one-year grace period before removing them from the reduced rate.
A correction, November 14, 2026: an earlier version of this page listed DMDC verification before all adverse actions and ongoing DOJ monitoring as settlement terms, and attributed the repossessions to Capital One Auto Finance. The DOJ’s announcement does not say either; the list above follows it.
What went wrong
Capital One’s case shows how SCRA exposure crosses business lines. The rate cap requests, the foreclosures, the repossessions, and the default judgments each happened in a different part of the bank, and each had the same underlying gap: a servicemember’s protected status, once known, did not reliably reach the team taking the action.
The enterprise-wide rate relief in the settlement is the clearest sign of that. A servicemember who sent orders to the credit card unit could still be charged more than 6% on an auto loan held elsewhere in the same company. The settlement required the bank to close that gap by treating one request as a request for every account.
What would have prevented it
One record of military status for the whole institution. When a servicemember invokes the SCRA anywhere, every business line should see it. That is the control the DOJ’s enterprise-wide remedy imposed.
A status check inside each adverse action workflow. Foreclosure, repossession, and a default judgment motion each need their own check at the time the action is taken, because status changes and each action has its own legal test.
Rate cap processing that is measured, not assumed. Two of the five allegations were about the 6% cap: requests denied, and benefits granted but miscalculated. An institution should be able to show, account by account, that the rate was reduced and the excess interest forgiven.
Why this case matters
SCRA compliance is enterprise-wide. If your institution has several credit products, each carries its own SCRA risk, and a program that covers one line leaves the others exposed.
Small referrals become large cases. One servicemember’s credit card problem, referred by one Air Force legal office, became a review of five years of accounts across the bank.
Acquisitions bring audits. The settlement reached into portfolios Capital One had only recently bought, and required independent audits of them.
Sources: DOJ press release, July 26, 2012; Capital One consent order (DOJ, PDF); 50 U.S.C. §§ 3931, 3937, 3952, 3953. All checked November 14, 2026. The claims in the complaint were allegations, resolved by consent order.
Disclaimer: This content is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. SCRA obligations depend on your institution's specific facts and on applicable federal and state law. Consult qualified counsel before acting on anything you read here.
See how civrel.io prevents these violations
Automated DMDC verification before every adverse action, consent-decree-grade documentation, and continuous monitoring.