← Enforcement Tracker | Banking & Mortgage

Bank of America's SCRA Foreclosure Settlement: $35.4 Million to 286 Servicemembers

Published · Updated

Settlement
$35,369,756
Year
2011
Servicemembers
286
Jurisdiction
C.D. California

This violation could have been prevented with automated SCRA compliance. Watch free training or see how Civrel works.

On May 26, 2011, the Department of Justice announced a settlement with BAC Home Loans Servicing LP, a Bank of America subsidiary formerly known as Countrywide Home Loans Servicing LP. The complaint, filed in the Central District of California, alleged that Countrywide foreclosed on about 160 servicemembers between January 2006 and May 2009 without the court orders the Servicemembers Civil Relief Act requires, and that it did not consistently check the military status of borrowers it foreclosed on through at least May 31, 2009. The DOJ called it the largest SCRA settlement it had ever reached.

The settlement opened with a $20 million fund. Because Countrywide also agreed to pay every servicemember it had wrongfully foreclosed on through the end of 2010, the number grew as the review went on. By February 2015 the DOJ reported that 286 servicemembers and their co-borrowers were receiving $35,369,756 under this settlement.

A correction, November 14, 2026: an earlier version of this page described this case as part of the 2012 National Mortgage Settlement, gave the total as “over $35 million” for “265+” servicemembers, and said it resolved interest rate cap claims. The 2011 decree predates the National Mortgage Settlement and covered non-judicial foreclosures only. The figures above are the DOJ’s own.

What the DOJ alleged

The case rests on one provision. Under 50 U.S.C. § 3953(c), a sale, foreclosure, or seizure of property on a mortgage that the servicemember took out before entering military service is not valid if it happens during military service, or within one year after it ends, unless a court orders it first or the servicemember signs a valid waiver.

In a judicial foreclosure state, the court process gives that protection a natural checkpoint. In a non-judicial state, where a trustee can sell the home without a lawsuit, nothing in the ordinary process stops to ask whether the borrower is serving. According to the DOJ, Countrywide foreclosed in many cases where it knew, or should have known, that the borrower was in the military, and some of those borrowers had served in Iraq and Afghanistan. The investigation began with a referral from the U.S. Marine Corps about one active-duty servicemember facing foreclosure.

From the DOJ’s announcement of the decree and its November 2011 update:

  • A $20 million settlement fund for servicemembers foreclosed on between January 1, 2006 and May 31, 2009
  • Compensation for any additional SCRA-protected borrower foreclosed on without a court order between June 1, 2009 and December 31, 2010
  • A minimum of $116,785 per servicemember, plus any lost equity with interest
  • Repair of negative credit report entries tied to the foreclosures, and no collection of any remaining mortgage balance
  • SCRA training for employees and agents, revised SCRA policies and procedures, and referral of future SCRA complaints to the Justice Department
  • A check of the Defense Manpower Data Center (DMDC) website and the bank’s own files before any foreclosure, with no foreclosure in violation of the SCRA when the borrower is in military service or otherwise protected

Borrowers whose foreclosure happened in 2009 or 2010 could also receive money from the separate federal banking regulators’ settlement, which brought their total to $125,000 plus equity where it applied.

The second wave: judicial foreclosures

The 2011 decree did not settle everything. When the DOJ announced the National Mortgage Settlement on February 9, 2012, it said it had not released any potential claims against Bank of America for judicial foreclosures or for violations of the 6% interest rate cap. Those were handled under the 2012 settlement’s SCRA review.

That review covered foreclosures where a servicer obtained a default judgment without filing a proper affidavit stating whether the borrower was in military service. In September 2015 the DOJ reported that Bank of America owed $63,686,567 to 490 servicemembers and co-borrowers for judicial foreclosures, on top of the $35.4 million already flowing for non-judicial ones. Across the five largest servicers, foreclosure compensation reached more than $311 million for 2,413 servicemembers and co-borrowers.

What went wrong

The DOJ’s description points to one gap: military status was not checked consistently before foreclosure. Everything else in the case follows from that.

Non-judicial foreclosure removes the court as a backstop. A judge asks for a military status affidavit before entering a default judgment. A trustee sale does not. A servicer that forecloses non-judicially has to build the check into its own process, because no one else will run it.

The check has to run on every file, not most of them. The DOJ said Countrywide did not “consistently” check status. A step that runs on most files but can be skipped under volume produces exactly the kind of list that ended up in this decree: hundreds of individual families, each owed six figures.

The obligation followed the loans. The foreclosures at issue were Countrywide’s, starting in 2006, and the bill was paid by BAC Home Loans Servicing, the Bank of America subsidiary that Countrywide’s servicing business became. A servicer that takes on another company’s portfolio takes on its SCRA history too.

Lessons for the industry

Price the exposure per file. The minimum payment was $116,785 per servicemember, plus lost equity and interest, and later DOJ settlements used $125,000. Multiply that by the number of foreclosures run without a status check and the cost of skipping the check is plain.

Check at the point of sale, not only at referral. Military status changes. A borrower who was a civilian when the loan went delinquent may be on active duty, or inside the one-year post-service window, by the sale date.

Keep the evidence. The decree required a DMDC check before every foreclosure. When an examiner or the DOJ asks, the record of that check, with its date and result, is the answer.

How Civrel helps

Civrel is built around the control this decree required: a documented military status check before an adverse action proceeds.

A status check before every foreclosure step. Civrel records a DMDC verification for the borrower and keeps the result with the file, so a foreclosure does not move forward on an unchecked account.

The post-service window, not just current status. Section 3953 protects borrowers for one year after service ends. Civrel tracks service end dates so that a borrower who has just left active duty is still flagged.

An audit trail for every check. Each verification is stored with its date, the result, and who ran it, which is the evidence a consent decree like this one asks a servicer to keep.


Sources: DOJ press release, May 26, 2011 (settlement announcement); DOJ press release, November 10, 2011 (compensation minimum); DOJ press release, February 9, 2012 (claims not released); DOJ press release, April 4, 2013; DOJ press release, February 9, 2015 (non-judicial payments by servicer); DOJ press release, September 30, 2015 (judicial payments by servicer); 50 U.S.C. § 3953. All checked November 14, 2026. The claims in the complaint were allegations, resolved by consent decree.

Disclaimer: This content is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. SCRA obligations depend on your institution's specific facts and on applicable federal and state law. Consult qualified counsel before acting on anything you read here.

See how civrel.io prevents these violations

Automated DMDC verification before every adverse action, consent-decree-grade documentation, and continuous monitoring.